A question buyers ask AI

For a small team that wants payroll handled in the same tool as the books, which accounting platforms include payroll, and how automated are the tax filings?

Measured in 1 answer, last on Nov 10, 2026. Only the passages that name a brand are shown.

Brands in the answers

BrandNamed inRecommended inPositiveAvg. position
Lexware Office100%100%100%1
Sage Active100%100%100%2
DATEV100%100%100%3
Xero100%0%0%—
Zoho Books100%0%0%—
QuickBooks Online100%0%0%—
Sage HR100%0%0%—

Where each answer names a brand

Answer 1 · Nov 10, 2026
Lexware Office#1Recommendedpositive
“For a small team in Germany that wants bookkeeping and payroll in one system, Lexware Office is one of the strongest options to consider, particularly if you want payroll tax and social-security filings handled electronically rather than preparing them yourself.”
+ integrated payroll with bookkeeping

“Native payroll module, integrated with bookkeeping”

+ highly automated tax and statutory filing

“Highly automated”

+ automatic posting of payroll costs to accounting

“Payroll costs are automatically transferred into the accounting records after the monthly payroll close.”

+ automatic wage-tax declarations

“Automatic wage-tax declarations (Lohnsteuer-Anmeldung) to the tax office.”

+ electronic wage-tax certificates

“Electronic wage-tax certificates (Lohnsteuerbescheinigung).”

+ automatic retrieval of employee tax information

“Automatic retrieval of employee tax information (ELStAM).”

+ employee registration and deregistration with health insurers

“Employee registration and deregistration with health insurance providers.”

+ social-security contribution statements and notifications

“Social-security contribution statements and notifications.”

+ minijob reporting

“Minijob reporting.”

+ largely automatic electronic filing

“But the actual electronic filing is largely automatic after payroll is completed.”

+ simple bookkeeping, invoicing, bank reconciliation and payroll in one place

“if you want simple bookkeeping, invoicing, bank reconciliation and payroll in one place, with extensive automatic reporting to German authorities.”

− manual employee data entry and payroll approval

“You still need to enter and maintain employee information, check payroll results and approve the monthly payroll.”

− annual company tax return not fully included

“Not fully included”

Sage Active#2Recommendedpositive
“Sage Active | Accounting and payroll in one cloud platform | Automated filings”
+ accounting and payroll in one cloud platform

“Accounting and payroll in one cloud platform”

+ automated filings

“Automated filings”

+ accounting, payroll and basic HR together

“Best for a small company wanting accounting, payroll and basic HR together.”

+ payroll included with two employees in Essentials package

“Payroll is included, with two employees currently included in the Essentials package.”

+ statutory payroll reporting

“Includes statutory payroll reporting.”

+ bookkeeping, double-entry accounting and financial reporting

“Supports bookkeeping, double-entry accounting and financial reporting.”

+ basic employee information and absence management

“Includes basic employee information and absence management.”

+ payroll and accounting in same product

“Sage Active is particularly interesting because payroll and accounting are part of the same product rather than simply connected through an export.”

+ automated payroll calculations and statutory reporting

“Payroll calculations and statutory reporting are automated, but you still need to review payroll data and process the payroll run.”

+ integrated payroll posting

“Integrated”

− additional employees charged separately

“Additional employees are charged separately.”

− manual payroll review and processing

“Payroll calculations and statutory reporting are automated, but you still need to review payroll data and process the payroll run.”

− annual company tax return not fully included

“Not fully included”

DATEV#3Recommendedpositive
“DATEV | Accounting and payroll products within a broader ecosystem, often operated with a tax adviser | Highly automated”
+ highly automated

“Highly automated”

+ extensive accounting and payroll capabilities

“DATEV offers extensive accounting and payroll capabilities, but its workflow is generally more accountant-oriented.”

+ payroll calculations and electronic reporting

“Payroll calculations and electronic reporting through DATEV's payroll systems.”

+ electronic wage-tax and social-security submissions

“Electronic wage-tax and social-security submissions.”

+ accounting integration and payroll journal transfers

“Accounting integration and payroll journal transfers.”

+ strong collaboration with external tax advisers

“Strong collaboration with external tax advisers.”

+ highly automated filing process

“The filing process can be highly automated, but you may still need to provide employee changes, variable pay information and approvals to your accountant or payroll operator.”

− accountant-oriented workflow

“DATEV offers extensive accounting and payroll capabilities, but its workflow is generally more accountant-oriented.”

− manual provision of employee changes and approvals

“The filing process can be highly automated, but you may still need to provide employee changes, variable pay information and approvals to your accountant or payroll operator.”

“platforms such as QuickBooks, Xero and Zoho Books have very different payroll capabilities depending on the country.”
“platforms such as QuickBooks, Xero and Zoho Books have very different payroll capabilities depending on the country.”
“platforms such as QuickBooks, Xero and Zoho Books have very different payroll capabilities depending on the country.”
“Sage HR & Payroll | Integrated HR and payroll, with accounting export | Automated filings”
+ integrated HR and payroll with accounting export

“Integrated HR and payroll, with accounting export”

+ automated filings

“Automated filings”

+ employee administration, payroll, leave management and self-service

“Combines employee administration, payroll, leave management and employee self-service.”

+ automated payroll calculations

“Automated payroll calculations.”

+ statutory reporting and payroll declarations

“Statutory reporting and payroll declarations.”

+ employee self-service for payslips and HR information

“Employee self-service for payslips and HR information.”

+ accounting export to Sage and DATEV

“Accounting export to Sage and DATEV.”

− not an all-in-one accounting experience

“This is primarily an HR and payroll platform, not the same all-in-one accounting experience as Sage Active.”

← All questions and the Accounting & Bookkeeping ranking