A prompt buyers ask AI

Which backup and disaster recovery options have immutable or air-gapped copies that actually hold up against ransomware?

Measured in 1 answer, last on Nov 18, 2026. Only the passages that name a brand are shown.

Brands in the answers

BrandNamed inRecommended inPositiveAvg. position
Rubrik100%100%100%1
Cohesity100%100%100%2
Commvault100%100%100%3
Druva100%100%100%5
Veeam Data Cloud100%100%100%—
AWS100%100%100%—
Azure100%100%100%—

Where each answer names a brand

Answer 1 · Nov 18, 2026 · 11 sources cited
Rubrik#1Recommendedpositive
“1. Rubrik – Strong choice for enterprise cyber recovery”
+ immutable backups

“- Immutable backup copies.”

+ isolated off-site copies

“- Rubrik Cloud Vault for isolated, off-site copies.”

+ role-based access control

“- Role-based access control.”

+ multi-person approval

“- Multi-person approval (quorum authorization).”

+ anomaly detection

“- Anomaly detection to identify suspicious backup activity.”

+ clean environment recovery

“- Recovery of data into clean environments.”

+ enterprise cyber resilience

“Rubrik is particularly interesting because it was designed with cyber resilience as a central part of its architecture.”

Cohesity#2Recommendedpositive
“2. Cohesity FortKnox – Particularly strong for isolated cyber vaulting”
+ immutable and encrypted copies

“- Immutable and encrypted copies.”

+ logically air-gapped storage

“- Logically air-gapped storage.”

+ separate administrative controls

“- Separate administrative controls.”

+ MFA and quorum-based approval

“- MFA and quorum-based approval for critical operations.”

+ malware scanning and threat detection

“- Malware scanning and threat detection.”

+ clean-room recovery

“- Clean-room recovery.”

+ isolated cyber vault

“The separate cyber vault reduces the likelihood that an attacker who compromises production or the regular backup infrastructure can destroy every recovery copy.”

Commvault#3Recommendedpositive
“3. Commvault – Strong for complex enterprise environments”
+ heterogeneous environment support

“Commvault is worth considering for organizations with heterogeneous environments, including virtual machines, databases, physical servers, and cloud workloads.”

+ isolated backup copies

“- Isolated backup copies.”

+ immutable storage

“- Immutable storage.”

+ separate security domains

“- Separate security domains.”

+ cyber recovery orchestration

“- Cyber recovery orchestration.”

+ clean-room recovery

“- Clean-room recovery capabilities.”

+ flexibility

“Why I like it: Flexibility. It is particularly relevant when an organization has multiple platforms and cannot standardize everything on one infrastructure.”

Druva#5Recommendedpositive
“5. Druva – Strong cloud-native, managed backup option”
+ cloud-native architecture

“Druva takes a different approach: its cloud-native architecture reduces the amount of backup infrastructure you need to operate.”

+ immutable cloud backups

“- Immutable cloud backups.”

+ logical isolation from production

“- Logical isolation from production.”

+ separation of administrative privileges

“- Separation of administrative privileges.”

+ Data Lock

“- Data Lock to protect retention settings.”

+ threat detection and backup scanning

“- Threat detection and backup scanning.”

+ recovery workflows and quarantine

“- Recovery workflows and quarantine capabilities.”

+ less infrastructure to manage

“Why I like it: Less infrastructure to manage and fewer on-premises components that attackers can compromise.”

Veeam Data CloudRecommendedpositive
“4. Veeam – Excellent when implemented with proper security architecture”
+ hardened Linux repository

“Its hardened Linux repository provides:”

+ WORM-style immutability

“- WORM-style immutability.”

+ protection against backup modification and deletion

“- Protection against backup modification and deletion during the immutability period.”

+ single-use credentials

“- Single-use credentials.”

+ reduced credential exposure

“- Reduced exposure of repository credentials.”

+ separate backup infrastructure support

“- Support for separate backup infrastructure.”

+ cloud-based vault options

“Veeam also offers cloud-based vault options.”

+ VMware/Hyper-V/mixed infrastructure fit

“Veeam is a particularly attractive option for organizations already using VMware, Hyper-V, or mixed infrastructure.”

− hardened repository is not automatically air-gapped

“Important: A hardened repository is not automatically an air-gapped backup.”

AWSRecommendedpositive
“6 | AWS Backup | AWS-centric environments”
+ logically air-gapped vaults

“supports logically air-gapped vaults.”

+ immutable backup storage

“- Immutable backup storage.”

+ encryption

“- Encryption.”

+ cross-account recovery

“- Cross-account recovery capabilities.”

+ separation from production permissions

“- Separation from ordinary production permissions.”

+ S3 Object Lock WORM protection

“AWS | S3 Object Lock | WORM protection for backup objects”

− documented limitations for certain resources and cross-region configurations

“One important consideration: AWS documents limitations for certain resources and cross-region backup configurations.”

AzureRecommendedpositive
“7 | Azure Backup | Microsoft-centric environments”
+ immutable backup vaults

“- Immutable backup vaults.”

+ multi-user authorization

“- Multi-user authorization.”

+ soft delete

“- Soft delete.”

+ role-based access controls

“- Role-based access controls.”

+ logically air-gapped backup storage

“- Logically air-gapped backup storage.”

− logically air-gapped vault is not a physical offline air gap

“An important distinction: Azure's logically air-gapped vault is not a physical offline air gap.”

Sources the answers cite

← All prompts and the Backup & Disaster Recovery ranking