“### 4. Druva — multiple policies, but overwrite is the default”
“offers four useful restore policies:”
“Druva therefore provides good non-destructive capabilities but doesn't make them the default.”
“The problem is that Always overwrite is selected by default in the documented file-server restore workflow.”
“### 3. Veeam — flexible, but workflow-dependent”
“offers several overwrite policies:”
“It also supports restoring to a different location.”
“For NAS restores, Veeam documents a Leave option that preserves the existing target file, and an OverwriteIfOlder option that replaces it only when the backed-up version is newer.”
“However, the precise default depends on the restore workflow and interface/API being used.”
“I wouldn't classify Veeam as having a universally non-destructive default without validating the specific recovery path.”
“### 5. Cohesity — explicit overwrite control, unsafe API default”
“exposes an overwrite parameter in its file restore API.”
“The documented API default is true.”
“This means automation that doesn't explicitly set the parameter can overwrite existing production files.”
“Verdict: Non-destructive restore is supported, but the documented API default isn't protective.”
“### 2. Commvault — protects newer files through version comparison”
“If the destination file is newer than the backup, skip it.”
“Unconditional overwrite is an optional setting and is disabled by default in the documented configuration.”
“This is a good example of intelligent overwrite protection, rather than simply restoring everything to another location.”
“One caveat: behavior differs across agents and workloads.”
“### 1. AWS Backup — strongest non-destructive default”
“Creates a new resource when restoring most supported resource types.”
“Leaves the original resource intact.”
“Allows you to validate the recovered resource before switching production over.”
“S3 restores skip objects that already exist with the same name or version ID.”
“EFS full restores go into a recovery directory rather than replacing the existing filesystem.”
“Has exceptions, including Amazon Redshift Serverless and SAP HANA on EC2, where restores can overwrite existing data.”
