A prompt buyers ask AI

My supporters keep asking for a private community space alongside my paid tiers. How should I evaluate platforms that include community features?

Measured in 1 answer, last on Nov 20, 2026. Only the passages that name a brand are shown.

Brands in the answers

BrandNamed inRecommended inPositiveAvg. position
Patreon100%100%100%1
Kajabi100%100%100%—
Mighty Networks100%100%100%—
Circle100%100%100%—
Discord100%100%100%—
Ko-fi100%0%0%—
Substack100%0%0%—
YouTube Memberships100%0%0%—

Where each answer names a brand

Answer 1 · Nov 20, 2026 · 10 sources cited
Patreon#1RecommendedSite citedpositive
“Patreon is particularly interesting if you already have paid supporter tiers.”
+ Built-in community chats

“- Built-in community chats.”

+ Customizable chat spaces

“- Up to 10 customizable chat spaces.”

+ Tier-restricted chats

“- Chats can be restricted to specific membership tiers.”

+ No separate community account

“- Members don't need a separate community account.”

+ Integration with existing memberships

“- Integrates community access with existing memberships.”

− Less flexibility in community design

“- Less flexibility in designing a completely independent community experience.”

− Less suitable for courses and customization

“- Less suitable if you want sophisticated courses, structured learning, or extensive community customization.”

“Patreon, Ko-fi, YouTube Memberships, Substack, your own website, or somewhere else?”
KajabiRecommendedSite citedpositive
“Kajabi is worth considering if your paid membership includes substantial educational or exclusive content.”
+ Private community spaces

“- Private community spaces.”

+ Paid and free access groups

“- Paid and free access groups.”

+ Memberships and courses

“- Memberships and courses.”

+ Live events and discussions

“- Live events and discussions.”

+ Integrated offers and payments

“- Integrated offers and payments.”

− Excessive for simple private groups

“- Can be excessive if your primary requirement is simply a private supporter group.”

− All-in-one platform rather than lightweight add-on

“- More of an all-in-one business platform than a lightweight community add-on.”

Substack
“Patreon, Ko-fi, YouTube Memberships, Substack, your own website, or somewhere else?”
Mighty NetworksRecommendedpositive
“Mighty Networks combines community interaction with courses, events, and member experiences.”
+ Dedicated community spaces

“- Dedicated community spaces.”

+ Discussions, polls, and real-time chat

“- Discussions, polls, and real-time chat.”

+ Online and in-person events

“- Online and in-person events.”

+ Courses and livestreaming

“- Courses and livestreaming.”

+ Member engagement and gamification

“- Member engagement and gamification features.”

− More functionality than needed initially

“- More functionality than you may need initially.”

− Higher ongoing costs

“- Higher ongoing costs than simpler community solutions.”

CircleRecommendedpositive
“Circle is worth considering if you want the community to become a central part of your membership business.”
+ Customizable community spaces

“- Customizable community spaces.”

+ Paid memberships and subscriptions

“- Paid memberships and subscriptions.”

+ Discussion forums, chat, and member directories

“- Discussion forums, chat, and member directories.”

+ Events, live streams, and courses

“- Events, live streams, and courses.”

+ Custom branding and domain options

“- Custom branding and domain options.”

− Additional monthly platform costs

“- Additional monthly platform costs.”

− More setup and administration

“- More setup and administration than simply enabling a Patreon chat.”

DiscordRecommendedpositive
“Discord works particularly well when your supporters want to interact frequently.”
+ Text and voice channels

“- Text and voice channels.”

+ Tier-specific roles and permissions

“- Tier-specific roles and permissions.”

+ Real-time conversations

“- Real-time conversations.”

+ Strong mobile and desktop applications

“- Strong mobile and desktop applications.”

+ Integrations with membership platforms

“- Useful integrations with membership platforms.”

− Can become noisy and overwhelming

“- Can become noisy and overwhelming.”

− Requires thoughtful moderation

“- Requires thoughtful moderation.”

− Less suitable for long-form content

“- Less suitable for organizing long-form exclusive content.”

− Payment integration may require additional setup

“- Membership and payment integration may require additional setup.”

YouTube Memberships
“Patreon, Ko-fi, YouTube Memberships, Substack, your own website, or somewhere else?”

Sources the answers cite

← All prompts and the Creator Monetization & Digital Products ranking