“The strongest publicly documented option for large-scale phishing benchmarking is currently KnowBe4.”
“Its 2025 Phishing By Industry Benchmark Report analysed:”
“The dataset is unusually large and provides meaningful industry segmentation.”
“KnowBe4 also documents how its in-platform benchmarking population is selected: organisations must have completed comprehensive training at least once and conduct phishing simulations at least monthly.”
“That qualification matters: the comparison population is not representative of every organisation. It is a population of active KnowBe4 customers with established awareness programmes.”
“Hoxhunt and several other vendors are also worth evaluating.”
“The platform's behavioural approach is interesting, but its publicly available documentation does not establish the size and composition of its peer dataset as clearly as KnowBe4's.”
“The platform's behavioural approach is interesting, but its publicly available documentation does not establish the size and composition of its peer dataset as clearly as KnowBe4's.”
“Proofpoint offers benchmarking through its CISO Dashboard.”
“One interesting advantage is its connection to Proofpoint's wider email security and threat intelligence ecosystem.”
“The breadth of its security telemetry is attractive.”
“However, I would want Proofpoint to explain precisely which metrics are derived from real attacks versus simulated attacks, and whether the peer benchmark population is sufficiently large in your particular industry.”
“Mimecast offers industry benchmarking within its Engage awareness platform.”
“Importantly, Mimecast also has a separate Human Risk Insights capability that compares threat detections per user against distributions of other Mimecast customers.”
“Its peer-distribution approach is useful, but the population consists of Mimecast customers, not a representative sample of the wider market.”
“SoSafe is worth considering, particularly if you operate in Europe.”
“One useful distinction is that it measures more than simply clicking a simulated phishing email.”
“European behavioural awareness benchmarking | SoSafe”
“However, I would request the number of contributing organisations, industry distribution, geographic coverage and update frequency before treating the benchmark as statistically robust.”
“I would also consider the research published by .”
“This is valuable because it provides an independent framework for assessing the validity of vendor benchmarks.”
