“## 1. Sharetribe — Best overall match”
“Sharetribe has a customizable data schema covering users, listings, and transactions.”
“It supports four important data visibility models:”
“It also supports structured data, including strings, numbers, Boolean values, and nested JSON.”
“Sharetribe offers more marketplace functionality out of the box.”
“One distinction: Sharetribe's no-code transaction fields are primarily designed to collect information during checkout or offer submission.”
“## 2. Arcadier — Strong alternative, especially for B2B”
“Arcadier supports custom fields across several entities:”
“It supports structured fields such as text, numbers, dropdowns, checkboxes, dates, and more.”
“Its architecture also supports role-based access control for administrators, merchants, and buyers.”
“Important limitation: Its documentation confirms custom fields across all three relevant entities, but I couldn't verify equivalent per-field visibility controls (public, private, transaction participants, etc.) across all of them.”
“## 4. Kreezalid — Worth investigating”
“Kreezalid supports custom user attributes with visibility options:”
“It also has an API and supports listing metafields.”
“However, I couldn't establish that it offers the same configurable field-level visibility across users, listings, and orders.”
“## 3. Bubble — Most flexible, but requires development”
“Bubble isn't an out-of-the-box marketplace platform, but it offers considerable flexibility.”
“Its privacy rules allow you to define which users can see particular fields, based on conditions.”
“You can implement quite sophisticated access rules, including conditional permissions.”
“Bubble offers more flexibility for complex conditional rules, while Sharetribe offers more marketplace functionality out of the box.”
“The downside is that you must build the marketplace functionality and data model yourself.”
