A prompt buyers ask AI

We need role-based access, audit trails and compliance controls in our planning system. Which supply chain planning platforms do governance and security well?

Measured in 1 answer, last on Nov 19, 2026. Only the passages that name a brand are shown.

Brands in the answers

BrandNamed inRecommended inPositiveAvg. position
Oracle100%100%100%2
Kinaxis Maestro100%100%100%3
o9 Solutions100%100%0%—
Blue Yonder100%100%0%—
Anaplan Supply Chain100%100%100%—
SAP Integrated Business Planning (SAP IBP)100%100%100%—

Where each answer names a brand

Answer 1 · Nov 19, 2026 · 12 sources cited
Oracle#2Recommendedpositive
“For enterprise supply chain planning, I would put SAP IBP, Oracle Fusion Cloud Supply Chain Planning, Kinaxis Maestro, Blue Yonder, and o9 Solutions on the shortlist.”
+ predefined job roles and duty roles

“- Predefined job roles and duty roles.”

+ role-based function permissions

“- Role-based function permissions.”

+ data security policies

“- Data security policies.”

+ access restrictions by business unit and organization

“- Access restrictions by business unit and organization.”

+ restrictions by product, customer, supplier, and measure group

“- Restrictions by product, customer, supplier, and measure group.”

+ configurable auditing

“- Configurable auditing of business objects and attributes.”

+ recording of creation, modification, and deletion activities

“- Recording of creation, modification, and deletion activities.”

− auditing not enabled by default

“An important consideration: Oracle's auditing is not automatically enabled for every business object.”

Kinaxis Maestro#3RecommendedSite citedpositive
“For enterprise supply chain planning, I would put SAP IBP, Oracle Fusion Cloud Supply Chain Planning, Kinaxis Maestro, Blue Yonder, and o9 Solutions on the shortlist.”
+ role-based access controls

“- Role-based access controls and permissions.”

+ single sign-on support

“- Single sign-on support.”

+ user activity logging

“- User activity logging tied to individual user IDs.”

+ security log retention

“- Security log retention of at least 12 months, according to its Trust Center.”

+ SOC audits

“- SOC 1 Type II and SOC 2 Type II audits.”

+ ISO 27001 certification

“- ISO 27001 certification.”

+ security monitoring

“- Security monitoring and privileged-account reviews.”

o9 SolutionsRecommendedSite citedmixed
“For enterprise supply chain planning, I would put SAP IBP, Oracle Fusion Cloud Supply Chain Planning, Kinaxis Maestro, Blue Yonder, and o9 Solutions on the shortlist.”
+ security governance and risk management

“- Security governance and risk management.”

+ SOC 2-related assurance

“- SOC 2-related assurance.”

+ TISAX-related security assurance

“- TISAX-related security assurance.”

+ encryption at rest and in transit

“- Encryption at rest and in transit.”

+ administrative access controls

“- Administrative access controls.”

+ system monitoring, logging, and alerting

“- System monitoring, logging, and alerting.”

− application-level governance evidence needed

“My assessment: Worth evaluating, particularly for complex integrated planning environments, but obtain detailed evidence of application-level governance before making a decision.”

Blue YonderRecommendedSite citedmixed
“For enterprise supply chain planning, I would put SAP IBP, Oracle Fusion Cloud Supply Chain Planning, Kinaxis Maestro, Blue Yonder, and o9 Solutions on the shortlist.”
+ role-based access management

“- Role-based access management.”

+ least-privilege access principles

“- Least-privilege access principles.”

+ multi-factor authentication

“- Multi-factor authentication.”

+ independent security assessments

“- Independent security assessments.”

+ SOC attestations

“- SOC 1 and SOC 2 attestations.”

+ ISO certifications

“- ISO 27001 and ISO 27701 certifications for relevant services.”

− planning-level auditability unclear

“However, I would investigate the planning application's actual audit capabilities separately.”

Anaplan Supply ChainRecommendedSite citedpositive
“If governance, security, auditability, and regulatory compliance are major selection criteria, I would also evaluate Anaplan, particularly if your planning environment spans multiple business functions.”
+ role-based access controls

“- Role-based access controls.”

+ cell-level access controls

“- Cell-level access controls.”

+ centralized identity management

“- Centralized identity management.”

+ SAML-based SSO

“- SAML-based SSO.”

+ audit event tracking

“- Audit event tracking.”

+ SIEM integration

“- Integration of audit events with SIEM systems.”

+ encryption and BYOK

“- Encryption and optional Bring Your Own Key capabilities.”

− limited audit log retention

“One important detail: Anaplan Audit provides 30 or 90 days of logs, depending on the edition.”

SAP Integrated Business Planning (SAP IBP)Recommendedpositive
“For enterprise supply chain planning, I would put SAP IBP, Oracle Fusion Cloud Supply Chain Planning, Kinaxis Maestro, Blue Yonder, and o9 Solutions on the shortlist.”
+ key-figure-level access restrictions

“- Key-figure-level access restrictions.”

+ security audit logs

“- Security audit logs.”

+ permission filters

“- Permission filters to restrict access to planning data.”

+ attribute-level permissions

“- Attribute-level permissions.”

+ role-based authorization

“- Role-based authorization through business roles.”

+ configurable retention periods

“- Configurable retention periods for security audit log events.”

+ structured enterprise governance

“Best for: Organizations requiring structured enterprise governance and integration with SAP ERP.”

Sources the answers cite

← All prompts and the Supply Chain Planning ranking