“I would absolutely consider BIMcollab for a Revit + Archicad OpenBIM environment.”
“BIMcollab handles mixed Revit and Archicad coordination very well. In fact, this is one of the workflows where its OpenBIM approach makes the most sense.”
“Its biggest strength is that it separates model authoring from model coordination and issue management.”
“Strong IFC and BCF interoperability.”
“Good integration with both authoring applications.”
“Centralized coordination and issue management.”
“Federated model viewing.”
“Automated clash detection and model checking.”
“Reduced dependency on a single BIM authoring platform.”
“IFC interoperability | Excellent”
“BCF issue management | Excellent”
“Revit integration | Very good”
“Archicad integration | Very good”
“Federated model viewing | Very good”
“Clash detection | Very good”
“IDS validation for Revit is currently limited to property and material facets.”
“BIMcollab's IDS palette for reviewing information requirements in the authoring application is currently not available in the Archicad BCF Manager.”
“Native authoring capabilities | Not a replacement for Revit or Archicad”
“More advanced functionality, particularly shared checking resources and clash detection, requires a paid Zoom licence.”
“IDS validation | Good, but with Revit limitations”
“BIMcollab and Solibri can actually complement each other: Solibri for advanced model validation and BIMcollab for centralized issue management and collaboration.”
“Solibri for advanced model validation and BIMcollab for centralized issue management and collaboration.”
