“### A. Toast — Best all-in-one solution”
“Automatically collect tips from transactions.”
“Send approved tip distributions directly to Toast Payroll.”
“Multiple hourly pay rates.”
“Tips Paid: Employees have already received the money.”
“Downside: The full solution requires multiple Toast products. Toast Tips Manager is an add-on, and Toast Payroll is currently US-only.”
“## 2. An important alternative: 7shifts”
“It isn't a traditional POS system. Instead, it specializes in restaurant workforce management, scheduling, tip pooling and payroll workflows.”
“Its tip-pooling functionality allows restaurants to configure custom distribution rules and automatically calculate employee tip allocations.”
“### B. Square for Restaurants — Best for simplicity and flexibility”
“Equal distribution.”
“Square Payroll can automatically import credit-card tips and distribute them between employees according to the configured tip-pooling rules.”
“Tip importing is designed for W-2 employees.”
“### E. Clover — Best for simpler operations”
“Clover can track transactions and tips, but its tip-pooling and payroll automation capabilities depend more heavily on third-party applications and integrations.”
“It is worth noting that 7shifts identifies Clover as a sales-only integration in its POS integration documentation, meaning it does not provide the same labor and punch-data synchronization available with some other POS systems.”
“### C. SpotOn — Best for flexible payroll-provider integration”
“Automated tip pooling.”
“SpotOn Teamwork integrates with:”
“### D. Lightspeed Restaurant — Best for integration-based flexibility”
“Automatic POS tip-data imports.”
“Downside: You may need to manage multiple vendors and subscriptions rather than having everything in one native platform.”
